[Chapter-delegates] FYI What ten chapters said about the chapter charter

Dave Burstein daveb at dslprime.com
Fri Nov 6 09:27:08 PST 2026


Hi

Sorry for yet another email.  Claude summarized comments from Yuri
Kargapolov, Veni Markovski, Hank Nussbacher, Carlos Vera, Amrita
Choudhury, Winthrop
Yu, Borka Jerman, Nicolas Chagny, Johan Helsingius, Cheryl Langdon-Orr,
Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond, Berna Alp, & Pedro de Perdigão Lana. Please
correct mistakes and send me more to include.

I'm waiting for the details of the 30 other chapter submissions that will
be released without names. Claude will put them together so we have a clear
list of what needs to be discussed at the meeting.

We're all hoping to reach consensus but there's a long way to go. I worked
all night on some energy analysis for the new congress but got this out.
I'll work with everyone to organize things ahead of the meeting. It looks
to go 2-3 hours because there is so much so far unresolved.

I personally have made two suggestions for inclusion.
That ISOC is a multi-stakeholder organization that makes decisions by
informed consensus whenever practical
That the chapters be included in the decision about chapter funding during
the budget process and the board approval of the budget. That is not a
commitment to fund, just to openly discuss it.
--------------------------------------------
Draft Chapter Charter Agreement: Principal Suggestions by Person

Source: chapter-delegates thread "Final Call for Input on the Chapter
Charter Agreement," Sep 16 – Oct 6, 2026. Chapter representatives appear in
order of first post. ISOC staff and the ChAC Steering Committee chair come
last, since they offered process commitments rather than suggestions.
------------------------------
Chapter representatives Veni Markovski (ISOC Bulgaria)

   - Some of the proposed text has been proposed before and failed.
   - The feedback form's pre-populated answers narrow responses and imply
   chapters have no choice but to accept the changes.
   - Many changes aren't needed. Every few years ISOC brings new
   requirements, forcing bylaw rewrites and court re-registration, which cost
   money.
   - The draft follows US NGO norms and ignores cross-cultural differences.
   If these requirements are obligatory for every chapter, implementing them
   will be a problem.
   - National law takes priority over requirements from an outside
   organization the chapter isn't legally part of.
   - Desired outcome: no added burden, help for chapters that need it, and
   the rest left free to do their work.

Hank Nussbacher (ISOC-IL)

   - Publish an archive of submissions with the status of each comment or
   requested change.
   - Those who submitted comments should post them voluntarily to the list,
   since the ChAC can't.
   - Paragraph 1: define "Territory." Can territories overlap? Could a
   single apartment building qualify?
   - Section 3: require chapters to make their articles, bylaws and
   governing documents public.
   - B.1.b: define "Good Standing."
   - Supports updating the agreement in principle and applauds the Steering
   Committee for acting against organizational inertia.

Carlos Vera (ISOC Ecuador)

   - Justify the revision first: produce a documented assessment of the
   current agreement (what worked, what didn't, what problems exist) and name
   the body that decided a revision was needed.
   - Show evidence that the problems come from the agreement itself, not
   from implementation, evaluation criteria, resources or ISOC support.
   - Respect the legal, economic and cultural diversity of independent
   chapters; avoid uniform standards. Specific worries: residency, term
   limits, reporting, "good standing," and alignment with ISOC positions, all
   of which may force costly bylaw and registration changes.
   - Make submissions public. Submitter names can stay private, but content
   shouldn't be. Show traceably which comments were accepted, rejected or
   incorporated.
   - The agreement's age (eight years) isn't a reason to change it.
   Durability is a virtue, and chapters need stability.
   - Turning the Chapter DNA (Health, Resilience, Impact) into binding
   obligations risks replacing one compliance regime with another, built on
   harder-to-assess qualitative concepts.
   - Pursue Chapter DNA goals first through evaluation criteria, capacity
   building, incentives, shared tools and targeted support.
   - The ChAC should synthesize recurring themes, separate global from
   jurisdiction-specific issues, run a structured discussion among chapters
   and bring consolidated recommendations to the full ChAC. The feedback form
   is an input to deliberation, not a substitute.
   - Concrete proposal: ask chapters directly whether amending the
   agreement is the right instrument. Task the next Steering Committee with
   analyzing how to meet Chapter DNA goals without amending it, and amend only
   where the existing text is demonstrably an obstacle.
   - Open questions he wants answered: What alternatives were considered?
   What evidence shows a new Charter would produce healthier, more resilient
   chapters?

Amrita Choudhury (no chapter named in thread)

   - Many obligations are unrealistic for volunteers in much of the world.
   - A.5.a: ISOC can't require diversified local funding where local
   regulations prevent ISOC itself from funding chapters.
   - Hold multiple online feedback sessions before anything is finalized.

Winthrop Yu (ISOC-PH)

   - Publish other chapters' submissions and hold a public discussion,
   possibly on the chapter-delegates list.
   - The core issues remain legal registration and funding.
   - The 2018 Chapter Letter came with a promise of alternative funding
   channels to offset the bank-account requirement. That promise hasn't been
   kept in eight years, and now more requirements are coming.
   - Evaluate the effects of the 2018 Letter before writing a new one.
   - Local nonprofit regulation can be severe (e.g., Philippine
   anti-corruption oversight of nonprofits).
   - ISOC's US domicile may become a problem for non-US chapters under the
   current, and possibly future, US administration.
   - Backs Carlos's sequencing: establish justification first, then amend
   proportionately.

Borka Jerman (ISOC Slovenia)

   - Agrees with most comments, especially Carlos's.
   - Chapters differ greatly in legal status and economic and institutional
   environment.
   - Do an analysis before redesigning and re-adopting the agreement.

Nicolas Chagny (Internet Society France)

   - Hold a live discussion among chapters before the text is consolidated;
   written comments alone aren't enough.
   - Endorses all of the UK Chapter's points.
   - Supports the spirit of the revision (compliance to community,
   person-dependency to durable systems, volume to impact) but objects to
   translating it into binding obligations.
   - A.3.d (residency): apply only to key statutory roles such as president
   and treasurer, and reserve a defined share of board seats for non-residents.
   - A.4.a and B.1.f (administrative load): set an explicit effort budget.
   That means a short annual format with page or time limits, ISOC-provided
   templates, reuse of grant reports with no duplication, and acceptance of
   existing publications, positions and event records as evidence.
   - B.1.a: capacity-building support should reduce paperwork (shared
   tooling, staff assistance), not add to it.
   - Transition period: decouple it from the Charter's entry into force and
   make it long enough for chapters to amend bylaws (in France, a general
   assembly) and build a leadership pipeline that can meet term-limit,
   residency and succession requirements.

Johan Helsingius ("Julf," SIY – Finland Chapter)

   - Strongly supports flexibility on residency. He chairs the Finland
   chapter while living in the Netherlands, and several board members have
   lived in Brussels for work.

Cheryl Langdon-Orr (ISOC Australia; chapter inferred from her ASIC
reference)

   - The chapter is an ASIC-registered company limited by guarantee (since
   1995) and will follow Australian Corporations Law over the charter. That
   conflicts with several proposed provisions.

Olivier MJ Crépin-Leblond (ISOC United Kingdom Chapter; on behalf of its
Executive Committee)

   - Overall: some provisions would create legal and operational barriers
   to the UK Chapter remaining a chapter, and imposing national borders
   contradicts ISOC's global, bottom-up foundations.
   - A.3.c (chair/secretary/treasurer, no doubling up): agrees with the
   principle but sees it as top-down control with a weak legal basis.
   - A.3.d (residency): opposes. Members are mobile (students, placements,
   retirees abroad, frequent travelers in Internet governance), and the clause
   contradicts the borderless Internet.
   - A.3.g (meetings open and accessible to all members): limit it to
   in-person meetings and add "best effort." Fully accessible venues are often
   unaffordable, and sponsored or Parliamentary events require vetting (e.g.,
   Portcullis House, House of Lords events).
   - A.4.c (ISOC prior approval of governance changes): under UK company
   law this risks making ISOC a shadow director, with insolvency, fiduciary
   and insurance exposure. Limit approval to material changes and exclude
   company articles, membership terms and liability.
   - Article 5: replace "shall" throughout. Volunteer chapters can only do
   best effort, and "shall" implies staffing ISOC isn't paying for.
   - A.5.a (diversified funding): aspirational, not mandatory, especially
   since the ISOC Foundation competes for the same local funders.
   - A.5.c (impact measurement): unverifiable and intrusive as a "shall,"
   and it casts the chapter as ISOC's local tool.
   - B.1.f (comply with grant terms): redundant with grant agreements;
   remove it.
   - C.a (Rejuvenation): "extreme cases of misconduct" is undefined; ISOC
   shouldn't be able to shorten the cure period at its sole discretion.
   - T&C 1.a(iv) (chapter positions not contrary to ISOC positions):
   chapters sometimes diverge legitimately (ISOC France vs. Facebook, 2018),
   there's no clear way to know the official ISOC position, and the clause
   creates cross-jurisdictional liability. Soften it or remove it.
   - T&C 5 (Limitation of Liability): make it fully reciprocal.
   - T&C 6 (Amendments): restore the 2018 footnote. Substantive changes
   require community consultation through the ChAC and chapter delegates, and
   chapters sign the new version.

Berna Alp (Internet Society Switzerland Chapter)

   - Dispute Resolution cites the ICOM-WIPO Mediation Rules, which are for
   art and cultural heritage disputes. Replace them with the general WIPO
   Mediation Rules.
   - Add a governing-law clause stating that each chapter's internal
   governance stays subject to its own local law. Naming Geneva as the venue
   doesn't settle governing law.
   - Cap chapter costs in disputes with ISOC and have ISOC cover costs
   above the cap. WIPO arbitration costs a claimant at least USD 6,000 upfront
   before arbitrator and legal fees, which volunteer chapters can't afford.
   - Explain how arbitration relates to the appeal process under ISOC's
   Bylaws, and give chapters a free internal appeal step before arbitration.
   - A fuller ISOC-CH response is to follow.

Dave Burstein (ISOC New York)

   - The issues need a thorough public discussion; at least two other
   chapters are likely to vote against the draft.
   - Work toward consensus rather than forcing chapters into strong action.
   - NY board statement (out for approval): important requirements are
   missing from the draft; there is no consensus; delay 90 days to seek it.
   - Asked Flávio for a Zoom within days, open to the full NY board and
   anyone else.

Pedro de Perdigão Lana (ISOC Brazil, Vice-President)

   - Pair every concern with a concrete proposed fix; it grounds the
   problem and makes it easier to act on.
   - Read existing ISOC meeting notes and documentation before reopening
   settled debates.
   - Publish chapters' contributions to the review.
   - Avoid fully AI-generated comments; personal and collective opinions
   add more to the discussion.

Yuri Kargapolov (Ukraine Chapter)

   - Registering under Ukrainian law required harmonizing ISOC requirements
   with national legislation, reinforcing the point that local law shapes what
   chapters can adopt.

------------------------------
ISOC staff and ChAC Steering Committee (process commitments, not
suggestions) Christine Saegesser Baethge (Sr. Director, Chapters and SIGs,
ISOC)

   - Detailed comments were possible through the form's "other sections"
   option.
   - Iteration 2 is being drafted from feedback from about 30 chapters,
   followed by a second and final consultation round.
   - A special call will present Iteration 2 and explain how feedback was
   used, with French and Spanish interpretation.
   - Additional consultation formats beyond the form are under
   consideration.
   - Answered NY's call request by pointing to the planned special call as
   the next step agreed with the ChAC. My reading: a polite no to a separate
   NY call. She did not address the 90-day delay.
   - Stated goals: reduce volunteer burden, meet chapters where they are,
   reflect diversity, simplify requirements.

Flávio Rech Wagner (ChAC Steering Committee Chair; President, ISOC Brasil)

   - First-round submissions won't be published because submitters weren't
   asked for consent. The next round will include a consent checkbox.
   - A summary of themes and how they were addressed will be shared.
   - Anyone may post their own submission to the list, and the SC will try
   to track it.
   - Rationale for the revision: the ChAC 2026 Action Plan (Q1 call) and
   the Chapter DNA document (Q2 call).
   - ISOC Legal is involved in Iteration 2 to address legal diversity.
   - No intention to add burdens on volunteer-run chapters.

------------------------------
Clause cross-reference

   - *A.3.c leadership roles:* UK
   - *A.3.d residency:* France, Finland, UK, Ecuador (flagged)
   - *Term limits / succession planning:* France, Ecuador (flagged)
   - *A.3.g open meetings:* UK
   - *A.4.a / B.1.f reporting and admin load:* France, UK
   - *A.4.c ISOC approval of governance changes:* UK
   - *A.5 "shall" / Health-Resilience-Impact obligations:* UK, Ecuador (in
   principle)
   - *A.5.a diversified funding:* Amrita Choudhury, UK
   - *A.5.c impact measurement:* UK
   - *B.1.a capacity building:* France
   - *B.1.b "Good Standing":* Israel, Ecuador
   - *C.a Rejuvenation:* UK
   - *T&C 1.a(iv) alignment with ISOC positions:* UK
   - *T&C 5 liability:* UK
   - *T&C 6 amendments:* UK
   - *Dispute Resolution:* Switzerland
   - *Para 1 "Territory" / Section 3 public governance docs:* Israel
   - *Local law supremacy:* Australia, Bulgaria, Ukraine
   - *Process (justification, transparency, live discussion, delay):*
   Ecuador, Bulgaria, Philippines, Slovenia, France, Israel, Amrita Choudhury,
   New York, Brazil (Pedro)

------------------------------
Documents referenced in the thread

   - Current Chapter Charter Agreement:
   https://www.internetsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Chapter-Charter-Agreement.pdf
   - Proposed first draft:
   https://isoc.app.box.com/s/bmom76ebuq3m8s94gf1m4lb1vti02i32
   - Chapter DNA:
   https://app.box.com/notes/2184030150813?s=sm6wg879ouz0wcb3uuejbomrqypp1568
   - DNA-to-Charter mapping guide:
   https://app.box.com/notes/2286649326490?s=bphineozvfi6cldkx2irs166fji8qlyf
   - Sept 22 ChAC summary slides (first-round themes):
   https://isoc.box.com/s/e0ewjum8ysj1384xndu8sq5lt8s8yu16
   - May 2026 ChAC slides (revision process):
   https://isoc.box.com/s/hvx8e5irtauf5j4brxiu22e48svnkyj4



  Building aienergy.fyi and aipolicy.fyi. News worth a tweet @AInews_wire,
20 yrs tech reporting, 2 books, 11 conferences chaired. Occasional awards.
Always trying to get closer to the truth.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://elists.isoc.org/pipermail/chapter-delegates/attachments/20261106/7717ebee/attachment-0001.htm>


More information about the Chapter-delegates mailing list