[Chapter-delegates] Chapter Charter Agreement FAQ (was: Re: Sebastian Bellagamba agrees to work toward consensus on the chapters agreement

Christine Saegesser saegesser at isoc.org
Wed Nov 11 04:58:42 PST 2026


Dear Colleagues,

Thank you for the thoughtful questions and perspectives shared around the revised Chapter Charter Agreement. We know how important this agreement is to Chapters, and we want to make sure everyone has the information and opportunity to contribute.

I'd particularly encourage you all to read the Chapter Charter Agreement FAQ<https://isoc.box.com/s/ghm1z0yxw3f2ka0mtu47c7b8xgikxvij>, shared alongside Version 2 of the draft Agreement earlier in the week.

The FAQs address many of the questions that chapter leaders have raised with the ChAC Steering Committee and ISOC staff over recent weeks, including the reasons for the revision, next steps, and how final decisions will be made. These points will also be covered during tomorrow's Special ChAC Calls, and you should have all received an invite to participate.

We warmly welcome your continued input, feedback and discussion on Version 2 and look forward to the calls tomorrow.

Please also make sure to submit any feedback, support for and/or any remaining concerns about the latest version through the official consultation form<https://app.smartsheet.com/b/form/01a1b16b69427fe1a9905e6fb98afc9c> by 30 November. This helps us formally capture and consider every contribution consistently as we develop the final text. You can also find the clean and annotated Version 2 documents at this link.

Thank you again for your engagement and for helping us shape this agreement.

Best,

Christine

Christine Saegesser Baethge, Sr. Director Chapters and Special Interest Groups
saegesser at isoc.org

[7lLtdG5uyz62tLMy7C1sG4AZ0YbGncdFng.png]

On 11 Nov 2026, at 09:45, Borka Dzonova Jerman-Blazic via Chapter-delegates <chapter-delegates at elists.isoc.org> wrote:

+1,

Borka, ISOC Slovenia


On Sat, 7 Nov 2026, Winthrop Yu 楊宗超 via Chapter-delegates wrote:

+1 Carlos and Dave.
At this point, I am particularly looking at Carlos':

     How will consensus be assessed if substantive disagreements
     remain after November 30?
  - and -
     A consultation deadline should not prevent further dialogue
     where substantive issues remain unresolved.
WYn
PH
On 11/7/2026 2:27 AM, Berna Alp via Chapter-delegates wrote:
     Dear Christine, Flávio, Dave and colleagues,

     ISOC Switzerland supports the points raised by the Ecuador
     Chapter, in particular a consolidated record of proposals and
     responses, and a clear way to assess consensus.

     Two practical requests: as Dave and Carlos suggested, could
     Version 2 be shared a few days before the 12 November calls, so
     Chapters can prepare; and where concerns are addressed through
     implementation guidance rather than the Charter text, could this
     be clearly indicated, as guidance does not carry the same weight
     as the agreement itself?

     Thank you for the update.

     Kind regards,
     -Berna Alp
     ISOC Switzerland Chapter

     On 11/6/26 4:31 PM, Carlos Vera via Chapter-delegates wrote:

     Dear Christine, Dave, Flávio, and Chapter Colleagues,

     The Internet Society Ecuador Chapter welcomes the
     clarification regarding Version 2 and the commitment to
     explain how Chapter contributions have been considered.

     This is a positive step toward the transparency we have
     consistently requested.

     We believe three points remain important before the
     November 12 meetings (agree with Dave if we do not want to
     postpone have to have on time)

      1. How can Chapters propose agenda items and participate
         directly in presenting and discussing their positions?
      2. How will consensus be assessed if substantive
         disagreements remain after November 30?
      3. Will a consolidated record of proposals, responses,
         and unresolved concerns be available to all Chapters,
         while respecting legitimate confidentiality requests?

     As we have stated from the beginning, the objective should
     not be merely to complete a consultation process, but to
     build an agreement that responds to real needs, respects
     Chapter autonomy, and reflects the collective
     participation of Chapters.

     We trust the current ChAC Steering Committee to exercise
     its leadership and facilitate this process, with the
     active support of ISOC staff.

     A consultation deadline should not prevent further
     dialogue where substantive issues remain unresolved.

     Best regards,

     Internet Society Ecuador Chapter

     Carlos Vera

     El nov 6, 2026, a la(s) 10:09, Christine Saegesser
     via Chapter-delegates
     <chapter-delegates at elists.isoc.org> escribió:

     Hi Dave, Carlos, and other chapter leaders who have
     contributed to this discussion.
The upcoming consultation is indeed an important
opportunity for chapters and community members to review
Version 2 and provide further feedback. As discussed
during recent community calls, the current draft is not
final, and we strongly encourage broad participation.
Version 2 has been shaped by submissions, community calls,
discussions with chapter leaders, and direct conversations
with individual chapters. We will make clear how that
input was considered, including where it led to changes in
the draft and where issues are being addressed through
implementation guidance or related work.
At the Special ChAC Calls on 12 November, the ChAC
Steering Committee and Internet Society staff will walk
through the main changes between Versions 1 and 2, and
show how specific community input shaped the revised
language. We will also launch the second and final round
of consultation running through 30 November. Contributors
in this second round will have the opportunity to indicate
if they would like their input shared more publicly.
We encourage all chapter leaders to review Version 2 as of
next week, discuss it within their chapters, and highlight
any remaining concerns, unintended consequences, or areas
requiring further clarification.
We look forward to continuing the conversation with all of
you.
Best,
Christine
Christine Saegesser Baethge, Sr. Director Chapters and
Special Interest Groups
saegesser at isoc.org
<7lLtdG5uyz62tLMy7C1sG4AZ0YbGncdFng.png>

     On 11/6/2026 9:23 PM, Carlos Vera via
     Chapter-delegates wrote:

     Dear Dave and Chapter Colleagues,

     The Internet Society Ecuador Chapter
     welcomes the position expressed by Dave
     and the unanimous resolution of the New
     York Chapter Board. As we have
     consistently stated since the beginning
     of these exchanges, we believe that the
     revision of the Chapter Charter
     Agreement must be based on open
     dialogue, transparency, meaningful
     Chapter participation, and genuine
     consensus.

     It is worth remembering that many ISOC
     staff members, including Sebastian, have
     themselves come from the Chapter
     community. We expect their experience
     and understanding of the diverse
     realities of Chapters to be reflected in
     this process.

     Flávio, as Chair of the ChAC Steering
     Committee, also has an important
     opportunity and responsibility to
     provide the positive, inclusive, and
     proactive leadership that many Chapters
     have been calling for.

     The concerns raised by Chapters should
     not be interpreted simply as complaints
     or opposition. They include substantive
     observations and constructive proposals
     intended to strengthen both ISOC and its
     Chapters.

     We particularly welcome the proposals
     mentioned by Dave: recognizing
     consensus-based decision-making as a
     fundamental principle, preserving
     Chapter independence, and discussing
     financial support openly, including in
     the context of ISOC’s budget.

     As we have emphasized in previous
     exchanges, any new obligation should
     address a clearly identified problem, be
     supported by evidence, respect local
     legal frameworks, and be proportionate
     to the resources and volunteer
     capacities of Chapters. Likewise, ISOC’s
     commitments and responsibilities toward
     Chapters should be clearly established.

     To move forward constructively, the
     Internet Society Ecuador Chapter
     proposes a clear and practical
     methodology:

      1. Open discussion on this mailing
         list, as the primary forum where all
         Chapters can participate and follow
         the debate. Meetings and
         consultations should complement, not
         replace, this exchange.
      2. A shared and transparent record of
         proposals, including those already
         submitted by Chapters, with each
         concern, recommendation, and
         alternative clearly identified.
      3. Documented responses from ISOC,
         explaining which proposals are
         accepted, modified, or rejected, and
         why. Successive drafts should
         clearly show how Chapter
         contributions have been considered.
      4. A substantive review of new
         obligations and mutual commitments,
         including their justification, legal
         implications, implementation costs,
         and the support ISOC will provide.
      5. A genuine consensus-building
         process, allowing sufficient time
         for Chapter boards to discuss the
         issues internally, identify areas of
         agreement, and address outstanding
         differences before any final
         decision.
      6. A transparent conclusion, with a
         consolidated record of agreements,
         unresolved concerns, and the
         rationale behind the final proposed
         text.

     The consultation scheduled for November
     12–30 should be an opportunity to
     implement this methodology, rather than
     simply collect another round of comments
     on a revised document.

     Above all, we must remember that the
     Internet Society’s global reach and
     local presence are made possible through
     its Chapters. They connect ISOC’s
     mission with communities, institutions,
     and local realities around the world.

     Chapters must therefore be active
     participants in defining the problems,
     evaluating alternatives, and shaping an
     agreement that directly affects them—not
     merely recipients of decisions
     formulated elsewhere.

     We welcome Dave’s initiative to compile
     and openly share proposals and encourage
     the ChAC Steering Committee to assume an
     active role in organizing and
     facilitating this collective effort.

     The Internet Society Ecuador Chapter
     reiterates its willingness to contribute
     constructively to this process, as we
     have done from the beginning, bringing
     perspectives from Ecuador, Latin
     America, and the Global South.

     Our shared objective must be an
     agreement built on mutual respect,
     balanced responsibilities, Chapter
     autonomy, and genuine consensus,
     strengthening the Internet Society as a
     truly global, inclusive, and bottom-up
     organization.

     Best regards,

     Internet Society Ecuador Chapter

     Carlos Vera

     El nov 5, 2026, a la(s) 11:33,
     Dave Burstein via
     Chapter-delegates
     <chapter-delegates at elists.isoc.org>
     escribió:

     Hi
After a challenging phone call
Sebastian agreed that the way forward on
the new chapters agreement is to take
the time to work for consensus and move
us toward common goals.
I see Flavio has set another
consultation period for 12 to 30
November. Let's all take advantage of
that. Flavio - to whom should requests
to speak go?
The New York Chapter board
unanimously resolved:
"ISOC must now support a thorough
examination of the proposed charter. It
should be transparent and organized so
that many chapters participate.
As always, ISOC as a multi-stakeholder
institution, should try to decide by
consensus and only take a vote if
consensus could not be reached."
People from at least 11 chapters raised
serious objections just on the list and
I've heard from others.  I believe
staffers expect that things will move
quickly after the
One reassuring note, that I assume will
survive into the next draft, is
"The Chapter shall operate as an
independent entity with sole authority
over Chapter activities, governance,
membership, funding, and other matters."
Some of our proposals include:
"The Internet Society is a
multi-stakeholder organization committed
to making decisions via consensus
whenever possible with a fully informed
membership."
"Financial support for the chapters
shall be determined after an open
discussion, possibly as part of the
preparation of the budget and the review
by the board."
I'm putting together a list of proposals
from members & chapters I'll share
openly. Please send me a copy of any
proposals you make.
I don't want to do any of this; I'm
swamped with work. In addition, I'm a
New Yorker. We all know ISOC needs more
leadership from the Global South. I
welcome help and would be delighted to
share or hand over responsibility.
Forward
Dave
--
  Building aienergy.fyi and
aipolicy.fyi. News worth a tweet
@AInews_wire, 20 yrs tech reporting, 2
books, 11 conferences chaired.
Occasional awards. Always trying to get
closer to the truth.
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
As a Chapter Leader, you are automatically added to the Internet Society’s Chapter Leaders Community Group and the Chapter Delegates e-list, which is regularly synchronized with the Internet Society Chapter Portal (AMS): https://community.internetsociety.org.
The Internet Society has a legitimate interest to communicate with its chapter leaders, you will therefore remain subscribed for the duration of your term and will be unsubscribed automatically when your term ends.
Please note that the archive of this list is publicly accessible and may be viewed by anyone. By submitting information to this list and contributing to the communications, you acknowledge that the contents will be publicly visible.
View the Internet Society Code of Conduct: https://www.internetsociety.org/become-a-member/code-of-conduct/
-
Unsubscribe: https://app.smartsheet.com/b/form/9b6ef0621638436ab0a9b23cb0668b0b?The%20list%20to%20be%20unsubscribed%20from=Chapter-delegates

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://elists.isoc.org/pipermail/chapter-delegates/attachments/20261111/887bb6f5/attachment-0001.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: 7lLtdG5uyz62tLMy7C1sG4AZ0YbGncdFng.png
Type: image/png
Size: 6862 bytes
Desc: 7lLtdG5uyz62tLMy7C1sG4AZ0YbGncdFng.png
URL: <http://elists.isoc.org/pipermail/chapter-delegates/attachments/20261111/887bb6f5/attachment-0001.png>


More information about the Chapter-delegates mailing list