[Chapter-delegates] Sebastian Bellagamba agrees to work toward consensus on the chapters agreement
Winthrop Yu 楊宗超
winthrop.yu at gmail.com
Sat Nov 7 04:59:59 PST 2026
+1 Carlos and Dave.
I am particularly looking at Carlos':
> How will consensus be assessed if substantive disagreements remain after
> November 30?
- and -
> A consultation deadline should not prevent further dialogue where substantive
> issues remain unresolved.
WYn
PH
On 11/7/2026 2:27 AM, Berna Alp via Chapter-delegates wrote:
> Dear Christine, Flávio, Dave and colleagues,
>
> ISOC Switzerland supports the points raised by the Ecuador Chapter, in
> particular a consolidated record of proposals and responses, and a clear way
> to assess consensus.
>
> Two practical requests: as Dave and Carlos suggested, could Version 2 be
> shared a few days before the 12 November calls, so Chapters can prepare; and
> where concerns are addressed through implementation guidance rather than the
> Charter text, could this be clearly indicated, as guidance does not carry the
> same weight as the agreement itself?
>
> Thank you for the update.
>
> Kind regards,
> -Berna Alp
> ISOC Switzerland Chapter
>
> On 11/6/26 4:31 PM, Carlos Vera via Chapter-delegates wrote:
>>
>> Dear Christine, Dave, Flávio, and Chapter Colleagues,
>>
>> The Internet Society Ecuador Chapter welcomes the clarification regarding
>> Version 2 and the commitment to explain how Chapter contributions have been
>> considered.
>>
>> This is a positive step toward the transparency we have consistently requested.
>>
>> We believe three points remain important before the November 12 meetings
>> (agree with Dave if we do not want to postpone have to have on time)
>>
>> 1. How can Chapters propose agenda items and participate directly in
>> presenting and discussing their positions?
>> 2. How will consensus be assessed if substantive disagreements remain after
>> November 30?
>> 3. Will a consolidated record of proposals, responses, and unresolved
>> concerns be available to all Chapters, while respecting legitimate
>> confidentiality requests?
>>
>> As we have stated from the beginning, the objective should not be merely to
>> complete a consultation process, but to build an agreement that responds to
>> real needs, respects Chapter autonomy, and reflects the collective
>> participation of Chapters.
>>
>> We trust the current ChAC Steering Committee to exercise its leadership and
>> facilitate this process, with the active support of ISOC staff.
>>
>> A consultation deadline should not prevent further dialogue where substantive
>> issues remain unresolved.
>>
>> Best regards,
>>
>> Internet Society Ecuador Chapter
>>
>> Carlos Vera
>>
>>
>>> El nov 6, 2026, a la(s) 10:09, Christine Saegesser via Chapter-delegates
>>> <chapter-delegates at elists.isoc.org> escribió:
>>>
>>> Hi Dave, Carlos, and other chapter leaders who have contributed to this
>>> discussion.
>>>
>>> The upcoming consultation is indeed an important opportunity for chapters
>>> and community members to review Version 2 and provide further feedback. As
>>> discussed during recent community calls, the current draft is not final, and
>>> we strongly encourage broad participation.
>>>
>>> Version 2 has been shaped by submissions, community calls, discussions with
>>> chapter leaders, and direct conversations with individual chapters. We will
>>> make clear how that input was considered, including where it led to changes
>>> in the draft and where issues are being addressed through implementation
>>> guidance or related work.
>>>
>>> At the Special ChAC Calls on 12 November, the ChAC Steering Committee and
>>> Internet Society staff will walk through the main changes between Versions 1
>>> and 2, and show how specific community input shaped the revised language. We
>>> will also launch the second and final round of consultation running through
>>> 30 November. Contributors in this second round will have the opportunity to
>>> indicate if they would like their input shared more publicly.
>>>
>>> We encourage all chapter leaders to review Version 2 as of next week,
>>> discuss it within their chapters, and highlight any remaining concerns,
>>> unintended consequences, or areas requiring further clarification.
>>>
>>> We look forward to continuing the conversation with all of you.
>>>
>>> Best,
>>>
>>> Christine
>>>
>>> *Christine Saegesser Baethge,* Sr. Director Chapters and Special Interest Groups
>>> saegesser at isoc.org
>>>
>>> <7lLtdG5uyz62tLMy7C1sG4AZ0YbGncdFng.png>
>>>
>>>> On 11/6/2026 9:23 PM, Carlos Vera via Chapter-delegates wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> Dear Dave and Chapter Colleagues,
>>>>>
>>>>> The Internet Society Ecuador Chapter welcomes the position expressed by
>>>>> Dave and the unanimous resolution of the New York Chapter Board. As we
>>>>> have consistently stated since the beginning of these exchanges, we
>>>>> believe that the revision of the Chapter Charter Agreement must be based
>>>>> on open dialogue, transparency, meaningful Chapter participation, and
>>>>> genuine consensus.
>>>>>
>>>>> It is worth remembering that many ISOC staff members, including Sebastian,
>>>>> have themselves come from the Chapter community. We expect their
>>>>> experience and understanding of the diverse realities of Chapters to be
>>>>> reflected in this process.
>>>>>
>>>>> Flávio, as Chair of the ChAC Steering Committee, also has an important
>>>>> opportunity and responsibility to provide the positive, inclusive, and
>>>>> proactive leadership that many Chapters have been calling for.
>>>>>
>>>>> The concerns raised by Chapters should not be interpreted simply as
>>>>> complaints or opposition. They include substantive observations and
>>>>> constructive proposals intended to strengthen both ISOC and its Chapters.
>>>>>
>>>>> We particularly welcome the proposals mentioned by Dave: recognizing
>>>>> consensus-based decision-making as a fundamental principle, preserving
>>>>> Chapter independence, and discussing financial support openly, including
>>>>> in the context of ISOC’s budget.
>>>>>
>>>>> As we have emphasized in previous exchanges, any new obligation should
>>>>> address a clearly identified problem, be supported by evidence, respect
>>>>> local legal frameworks, and be proportionate to the resources and
>>>>> volunteer capacities of Chapters. Likewise, ISOC’s commitments and
>>>>> responsibilities toward Chapters should be clearly established.
>>>>>
>>>>> To move forward constructively, the Internet Society Ecuador Chapter
>>>>> proposes a clear and practical methodology:
>>>>>
>>>>> 1. Open discussion on this mailing list, as the primary forum where all
>>>>> Chapters can participate and follow the debate. Meetings and
>>>>> consultations should complement, not replace, this exchange.
>>>>> 2. A shared and transparent record of proposals, including those already
>>>>> submitted by Chapters, with each concern, recommendation, and
>>>>> alternative clearly identified.
>>>>> 3. Documented responses from ISOC, explaining which proposals are
>>>>> accepted, modified, or rejected, and why. Successive drafts should
>>>>> clearly show how Chapter contributions have been considered.
>>>>> 4. A substantive review of new obligations and mutual commitments,
>>>>> including their justification, legal implications, implementation
>>>>> costs, and the support ISOC will provide.
>>>>> 5. A genuine consensus-building process, allowing sufficient time for
>>>>> Chapter boards to discuss the issues internally, identify areas of
>>>>> agreement, and address outstanding differences before any final decision.
>>>>> 6. A transparent conclusion, with a consolidated record of agreements,
>>>>> unresolved concerns, and the rationale behind the final proposed text.
>>>>>
>>>>> The consultation scheduled for November 12–30 should be an opportunity to
>>>>> implement this methodology, rather than simply collect another round of
>>>>> comments on a revised document.
>>>>>
>>>>> Above all, we must remember that the Internet Society’s global reach and
>>>>> local presence are made possible through its Chapters. They connect ISOC’s
>>>>> mission with communities, institutions, and local realities around the world.
>>>>>
>>>>> Chapters must therefore be active participants in defining the problems,
>>>>> evaluating alternatives, and shaping an agreement that directly affects
>>>>> them—not merely recipients of decisions formulated elsewhere.
>>>>>
>>>>> We welcome Dave’s initiative to compile and openly share proposals and
>>>>> encourage the ChAC Steering Committee to assume an active role in
>>>>> organizing and facilitating this collective effort.
>>>>>
>>>>> The Internet Society Ecuador Chapter reiterates its willingness to
>>>>> contribute constructively to this process, as we have done from the
>>>>> beginning, bringing perspectives from Ecuador, Latin America, and the
>>>>> Global South.
>>>>>
>>>>> Our shared objective must be an agreement built on mutual respect,
>>>>> balanced responsibilities, Chapter autonomy, and genuine consensus,
>>>>> strengthening the Internet Society as a truly global, inclusive, and
>>>>> bottom-up organization.
>>>>>
>>>>> Best regards,
>>>>>
>>>>> Internet Society Ecuador Chapter
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> Carlos Vera
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>> El nov 5, 2026, a la(s) 11:33, Dave Burstein via Chapter-delegates
>>>>>> <chapter-delegates at elists.isoc.org> escribió:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Hi
>>>>>>
>>>>>> After a challenging phone call Sebastian agreed that the way forward on
>>>>>> the new chapters agreement is to take the time to work for consensus and
>>>>>> move us toward common goals.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I see Flavio has set another consultation period for 12 to 30 November.
>>>>>> Let's all take advantage of that. Flavio - to whom should requests to
>>>>>> speak go?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> The New York Chapter board unanimously resolved:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> "ISOC must now support a thorough examination of the proposed charter. It
>>>>>> should be transparent and organized sothat many chapters participate.
>>>>>> As always, ISOC as a multi-stakeholder institution,should try to decide
>>>>>> by consensus and only take a vote if consensus could notbe reached."
>>>>>>
>>>>>> People from at least 11 chapters raised serious objections just on the
>>>>>> list and I've heard from others. I believe staffers expect that things
>>>>>> will move quickly after the
>>>>>>
>>>>>> One reassuring note, that I assume will survive into the next draft, is
>>>>>>
>>>>>> "The Chapter shall operate as an independent entity with sole authority
>>>>>> over Chapter activities, governance, membership, funding, and other matters."
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Some of our proposals include:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> "The Internet Society is a multi-stakeholder organization committed to
>>>>>> making decisions via consensus whenever possible with a fully informed
>>>>>> membership."
>>>>>>
>>>>>> "Financial support for the chapters shall be determined after an open
>>>>>> discussion, possibly as part of the preparation of the budget and the
>>>>>> review by the board."
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I'm putting together a list of proposals from members & chapters I'll
>>>>>> share openly. Please send me a copy of any proposals you make.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I don't want to do any of this; I'm swamped with work. In addition, I'm a
>>>>>> New Yorker. We all know ISOC needs more leadership from the Global South.
>>>>>> I welcome help and would be delighted to share or hand over responsibility.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Forward
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Dave
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> --
>>>>>> Building aienergy.fyi and aipolicy.fyi. News worth a tweet @AInews_wire,
>>>>>> 20 yrs tech reporting, 2 books, 11 conferences chaired. Occasional
>>>>>> awards. Always trying to get closer to the truth.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> _______________________________________________
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://elists.isoc.org/pipermail/chapter-delegates/attachments/20261107/9c04b576/attachment-0001.htm>
More information about the Chapter-delegates
mailing list